Dear Idol fandom,
I was supposed to sew tonight.
No love,
brilliantsongI still think nothing changes.
1. Individual posts for fic were already banned in
ontd_ai. That policy isn't actually any different than it was this morning.
2. "Meme"-style fiction with requests and fills has been relegated to a sister community. I don't think the "memes" were getting out of hand, but as long as there's still a home for them somewhere, I don't mind.
I still think it was handled poorly, if only because it alienated people, but I also think that fans are essentially resilient folk. We'll find a way to express ourselves regardless of the restrictions that are put in place and who puts them there.
The Idol fandom in particular strikes me as bipolar: there are people who genuinely love American Idol and its contestants, and there are people who still consider it a guilty pleasure and claim to love it ironically. I think this year there are more people who fall into the latter category; I remember when I started watching and needed to inject a certain amount of irony into my love in order to allow myself to appreciate it. In that regard, this really is still a very young fandom, despite the fact that the show has been running for eight years.
But the people with the so-called "ironic" love -- who love it even though they feel they
shouldn't -- are those that in turn make it difficult for those of us who would more readily express our fandom. Look: I love this show. I love what it represents. I love that, even if only as a facade, it gives ordinary people a chance to really shine. I love that it gives me the inspiration to live my own life more fully. I don't think I should
have to veil that love behind a curtain of irony. Maybe this means that
ontd_ai isn't the place for me; I'm not sure.
Either way, I really do think that the fandom won't
really suffer. This is an adolescence; an adjustment period wherein the young community will fret and flounce and slam doors and rage and argue and at the end of the day, or week, love itself regardless, because a community is still a
community, and if no policies have actually changed, then really, there's no reason not to go back to business as usual, right?
This is still unlike any other fandom that I have ever been a part of. I'm still not sure why I care so much or why I've invested so much time and emotional energy in it when by all rights I should be sewing for Dragon*Con.
My only real theory on that is that I feel like some sort of custodian of young girls' feelings, which makes very little sense since I am neither mod nor particularly active member! I think, ultimately, I want to help people, and show them that it will be okay, that life's really not so bad, that you'll survive past high school or college or further pettiness, and I think, too, that all this drama is doing is fuelling that very same pettiness.
And it's
useless. Everyone will have what they want, in the end; there will be fanfiction and snark alike, just as there always has been. Some people don't like fanfiction; it just so happens that those people were also community moderators, and well ... I don't know. The haters are going to hate.
I suppose if there's anything I've learned from being in this fandom, it's that.
Do what you do. Like what you like. Speak up for yourself and learn how to stand out from the crowd and form your own opinions, because you're not going to be able to please everyone. This is
Idol, for crying out loud: the fandom is naturally divided on the basis of being formed around a
competition. There will be fans for every single contestant and thus there will be a huge difference of opinion among the fandom and look, you need to be prepared to deal with differences if you're going to participate. And it doesn't matter if that difference of opinion is whether you prefer one contestant to another or fanfiction to no fanfiction.
Something else you'd think this fandom would be aware of? Handling disappointment. Only
one contestant's fans get to celebrate a win; everyone else
doesn't win the title. Everyone else doesn't get what they want. I was lucky in that my favorite won for the past two years, but you know, I still had to suck it up and accept it when my second or third favorites got voted off in these past two seasons and when my favorite didn't get that far at all in season six. I'm sort of surprised that people aren't able to apply these same coping mechanisms to changes within the community dynamic -- whether it's the "originals" accepting that new members are an inevitability (really; what did they expect?) or the fic writers accepting the mods' decision to ban fanfiction (which I still think is ridiculous because it was fairly moderated in the first place).
So -- yes, there you go. I don't like the decision and I don't like the way that it was handled, but ultimately it isn't up to me and yes there are alternatives and no, the community is not going to ostracize every single fanfic writer that is also a member.
I really did have too much coffee today.